Compare
Both are modern, cloud-based platforms — so the UI-generation gap that defines other comparisons isn't the story here. The real difference is depth on US Medicare home health PDGM, pricing transparency, and AI positioning.
Side by side
| Carelytic | AlayaCare | |
|---|---|---|
| Published pricing | Yes — Starter / Pro / Enterprise listed on the site | Quote-based, not published |
| Modern cloud platform | Yes — built 2025-2026 | Yes — modern cloud platform |
| US Medicare HH PDGM depth | Core focus — 432 HHRGs, Grouper, LUPA, NOA, CY2026 data | Supported — confirm depth for your needs |
| OASIS-E2 across 6 CMS timepoints | Built in — all 10 sections | Supported on the platform |
| AI for coding / QA | OIG-safe, evidence-cited Coding Review | AI and data-science tooling |
| Billing & EVV | Included in every tier | Available — confirm scope in your quote |
| Mobile clinician experience | Installable PWA, offline outbox, voice dictation, signature canvas | Mobile apps with established offline support |
| Passkey / WebAuthn login | Built in — Touch ID / Face ID / hardware keys + trusted device | Standard 2FA (publicly documented) |
Comparison reflects publicly available product information as of 2026. AlayaCare updates its offering frequently — verify the current details in your own discovery process.
Where Carelytic wins
Carelytic's entire data model is US Medicare home health: 432 HHRGs with CY2026 weights, ~75K ICD-10 crosswalk codes, Grouper Preview, LUPA Risk, NOA Tracker, HIPPS-injected episode claims, OASIS-E2 across all six CMS timepoints. If Medicare home health is your core business, that depth is the difference.
Carelytic lists Starter / Professional / Enterprise pricing. AlayaCare pricing is quote-based. For a US agency that wants to budget before an evaluation, the published model is a real advantage.
Carelytic's AI Coding Review is explicitly engineered and marketed as compliance-safe — it cites chart evidence and never frames itself as reimbursement maximization. For US agencies watching OIG enforcement, that positioning matters.
Billing, EVV, PDGM, payroll, eligibility, fax, AI — all included on Starter. No module map. Confirm AlayaCare's scope-by-tier in your quote.
Carelytic ships WebAuthn / passkey login — Touch ID, Face ID, Windows Hello, hardware keys — plus a trusted-device second factor and offline chart drafts encrypted with WebCrypto. Most home health platforms still rely on TOTP-on-every-login. That gap matters as more agencies treat clinical software as a real security surface.
Why agencies switch
Most agencies don't switch platforms casually — it's a real project. These are the triggers we hear most often from agencies that moved off AlayaCare.
Book a demoCarelytic vs AlayaCare — FAQ
Both are modern, cloud-based platforms, so this isn't a legacy-vs-modern comparison. The meaningful differences are focus and transparency: Carelytic is purpose-built for US Medicare home health PDGM with published pricing and OIG-safe AI, while AlayaCare has strong roots in home care, scheduling, and telehealth across multiple markets.
For agencies whose core business is US Medicare home health, Carelytic's depth is built specifically for that: 432 HHRGs with CY2026 weights, Grouper Preview, LUPA Risk, NOA Tracker, HIPPS-injected episode claims, and OASIS-E2 across all six CMS timepoints. AlayaCare supports home health but its strengths also span home care and telehealth — evaluate based on what your core business is.
Carelytic publishes its pricing: Starter $350/mo, Professional $999/mo, Enterprise from $2,499/mo. AlayaCare pricing is quote-based and not published, so a direct comparison requires a quote scoped to your agency.
Keep comparing
Both run a home health agency end to end. The real difference is pricing transparency, whether core modules are...
Read the comparisonWellSky is a broad healthcare technology company spanning many care settings. Carelytic is purpose-built for US home...
Read the comparisonHomeCare HomeBase is built for large, enterprise-scale home health and hospice organizations. Carelytic is built for...
Read the comparisonMatrixCare covers skilled nursing, senior living, hospice, and home health under one vendor — broad, enterprise,...
Read the comparisonKanTime covers home health, hospice, pediatric, and private duty — broad across care lines, established in...
Read the comparisonBoth target mid-market home health agencies. The honest differences come down to pricing transparency, the mobile /...
Read the comparison